Hipness and its discontents

July 31st, 2005

Have you had it with hipsters? Well, good, because hipsters have had it—or so they say.

“I think people are exhausted by trends that have the half-life of a millisecond,” says John Leland, author of “Hip: The History.” “You live in a state of perpetual whiplash, in which the minute you’re up on one trend it’s gone and you should be on to another.”

Is hip over?And so the LA Times gives us a grouping of post-scenesters who have abandoned the loft-party life of pop-cultural exhibitionism to embrace the forgotten wonder of true life and actual conversation.

The take-away: Authenticity isn’t just for losers anymore.

Hipsters are resented, especially by themselves, for always going about as if nothing can touch them. The word evokes a particular brand of icily detached individualism—that knowing aloofness practiced by those who will never say just what they mean, who would in fact deny meaning (all is in flux!), yet are above being bothered to actually do so. They hide behind barriers, all the while parading before us, simultaneously protecting and projecting themselves.

But if the cool now seek the real…I do not believe it will be their first time.

The hip are our cultural seekers—self-identified outsiders who somehow will the self to push beyond its own alienation to go in search of the new, the hidden, the unlikely yet possible. Exalting the rare and deriding the common, they began their quest with the implicit belief that by rejecting the need to belong and by seeking more nuanced forms of engagement they would ultimately arrive at a purer kind of belonging.

Of course, nothing remains new, and once the arbiters of cool have spoken, the rare is less so; and soon the formerly exalted must also be derided. After each repetition of the cycle you are left with even less to hold onto, and even derision runs up against the law of diminishing returns.

So, is hip…over?

What a question. Of course the hip will always be with us. While the hipsters of our most recent yesterdays may abandon the militant pose, I suspect they cannot make a clean break. Their sensibility is too ingrained. (Besides: They’re addicts.) What’s more, every day brings new creation. As the splintering of culture accelerates, our long struggle to arrive at some kind of accommodation with modernity can only mutate into ever more arcane forms. (If you fear tomorrow, just think of the cartoons.) Hip can never be over.

And the carping? That’s surely not going away.

Being real is fine. We just wish people wouldn’t talk about it.

Tiny robot gains, abuses roaches’ trust

July 25th, 2005

Bird seems to grasp concept of zero

July 21st, 2005

Open your eyes: The ghoulishness of RCA

July 18th, 2005

Kids explain the internet for you

July 15th, 2005

Scones ruined

July 14th, 2005

I feel your pain—here, look at the graph

July 14th, 2005

Boy meets shark, a love story

July 12th, 2005

Librarian narrowly escapes bike bomb

July 12th, 2005

Telegrams still exist

July 9th, 2005

Alan Greenspan, father of electroclash

July 8th, 2005

Unlucky apartment numbers—and other mysteries of Japan

July 7th, 2005

Londoner adds ‘survive terror’ to 43 Things list

July 7th, 2005

Vivienne Westwood in my Imaginary Tokyo

July 6th, 2005